Mike Edison asks another:
I would also like to know if drawing the first performance position has an impact on judging. Do they have to leave “room” for higher scores later in the event? Does or should a chorus have to do anything different if they are early in the contest? Read More
Mike Edison asks
“When, in the judges view, does a performance begin and end?” As a quartet, I have received judges comments regarding how confident we looked as we came on stage. Does that influence the judges scores or just set an expectation? I ask this question from a chorus and/or quartet perspective.
Another from John Wabel
I have repeatedly asked that the society define and split the international/district competitions into a small chorus competition and a large chorus competition. I am in a small chorus and we don't even want to go to the district competition any more. There is no way we can compete with the large choruses. They tell me we can't change the district competition rules... Read More
From John Wabel
The society website refers to C & J as Contest & Judging. At Harmony College we were urged to not use the term "contest". We go to the district /international convention to have fun and see a show of the best that the quartets and choruses have to offer. I wish we could get away from the term "contest".
From Kirt Thiesmeyer
With the last chorus competitor, the Salem SenateAires, both Jim Henry and Jeff Oxley appeared on stage as part of the program. I was told by a Music Judge that all they need is a "paper membership" and they are authorized to be there, adding that, quite likely, the Salem chapter itself paid the necessary District and chapter dues to make it "kosher." Isn't that bot... Read More
From Al Spence
I’m puzzled by the scores awarded to the Salem chorus. I thought C & J was trying to enforce a cutting-down of the amount of talking in a contest set. This set lasted approximately 25 minutes, most of which was talking. This is supposed to be a contest, not a chapter show. Did they actually sing a complete barbershop arrangement? I totally lost track with all of th... Read More
From Stephanie Dingle:
How are members to handle situations when a judge, during evals, openly admits to crossing categories? A Presentation judge spends more time discussing singing or music ... a Music judge saying there was a lack of musicality but I scored higher because of energy.
These are a few vague issues I've heard myself, but I still question the idea that each category can be judged ... Read More
Despite our current judging system having been in place for almost 20 years, many of you still have questions about aspects of the judging system. Rumors and myths still abound. If you know a judge or feel bold, you may have contacted a judge in the past but many of you might never ask your question.
In an effort to help further educate, C&J (Contest and Judging) is hosting an interactive b... Read More
Thanks for visiting the blog concerning the 33% criterion. The position paper mentioned on page 24-25 of the July/August 2009 edition of The Harmonizer is here: 7th Chord Position Paper. A copy of the article in The Harmonizer is here: The Hallmark 7th Chord.
Although this is not technically a change to the definition of the barbershop style, this criterion has been used for almost 40 years i... Read More